Citadelle No Mistake Old Tom Gin

Zoe Chen — Old Tom Reimagined

10/10

Citadelle No Mistake Old Tom at 46% is a revelation. The French distillery has reimagined the Old Tom style with extraordinary elegance — the sweetness is perfectly calibrated, the botanicals are complex and vivid, and the finish is impossibly smooth. This is what Old Tom gin aspires to be. Absolute masterclass.

Marcus Blackwell — Subtle to a Fault

7/10

Citadelle's Old Tom at 46% is beautifully made, but the sweetness is so subtle that it barely registers as an Old Tom at all. If you want a clearly sweetened gin style, you may find this too restrained. The quality is high but the character is muted.

Jake Morrison — French Finesse Applied

8/10

When a prestigious French distillery tackles Old Tom, the result is predictably refined. At 46% Citadelle deliver a sweetened gin that is precise, elegant, and wonderfully drinkable. Quality through and through.